Tuesday, April 11, 2006

Engineering Reports Unfavorable to Insurance Industry Altered and Destroyed



The Biloxi Sun Herald has two new stories today on the alleged alteration and destruction of Hurricane Katrina-related engineering reports and other evidence that was unfavorable to the insurance industry on the wind vs. water question. An earlier post on this topic may be found here.

In "Engineer: Reports Altered, Name Forged
'They took out whole exhibits'
", Anita Lee reports:
Professional engineer James K. "Ken" Overstreet said his assessments of property damaged by Hurricane Katrina were altered without his permission and, in several cases, his signature was forged on documents insurance companies used to minimize or deny policyholder claims.

Overstreet worked as a contractor for S&B Infrastructure. In turn, S&B contracted with Rimkus Consulting Group Inc. to supply damage assessments to insurance companies. S&B, he said, parroted orders from Rimkus.

"If they could get by with changing the wind to surge, they would do it," said Overstreet, who has talked with the state Attorney General's Office in connection with a Hurricane Katrina insurance-fraud investigation. "If you had affidavits in there where people saw houses blowing down, sometimes they'd just take those out entirely. They took out whole exhibits."

The Sun Herald obtained copies of altered reports from the Merlin Law Group, which has subpoenaed the records for several lawsuits filed in Harrison County against Houston-based Rimkus, Rimkus employees managing Hurricane Katrina work, State Farm Fire & Casualty Co., Clarendon National Insurance Co. and the company adjusting Clarendon claims, CIG Group Inc.

Because of state Attorney General Jim Hood's ongoing investigation, representatives of S&B and State Farm said the companies will not comment on the allegations.

. . .

Overstreet said the engineering firms changed his reports without consulting him, even removing his references to tornadoes when he found evidence of them.

. . .

Overstreet said his signature was forged on the altered reports.

"I don't think there was any restriction on the extent to which they could change the report," Overstreet said. " I was told we didn't have any control over how the reports got changed. It was like it was almost none of my business how they got changed."

Overstreet said he saw a pattern to the damage investigations: when winds and surge battered property, blame the surge.

. . .

Overstreet completed a report on [homeowner James "Bud" Ray's] property in December. He concluded: "The home had been destroyed by a combination of wind gusts, tornadoes and wind-driven storm surge."

He added: "Due to the high incidence of snapped and uprooted trees, and according to eyewitness accounts, winds much higher than those considered to be "sustained" likely contributed to the structural damage to Mr. Ray's house."

A second Rimkus report in February omitted Overstreet's conclusions and instead said, "The storm surge associated with Hurricane Katrina destroyed the portion of the residence above the concrete foundation slab."

Ray had collected sworn eyewitness accounts of the devastation.

Overstreet's report included the eyewitness accounts and a map showing where each lived, along with a photo of Ray and one of the eyewitnesses. Those items were not included in the February report. Overstreet said his name was forged on the report as a consultant, with another engineer's signature and seal affixed.

Meanwhile, Ray spent $15,000 of his own savings on weather, engineering and other professional reports to buttress his claim that wind tore up his waterfront home before the water arrived. He kept CGI representatives abreast of his expert information, eventually securing $500,000 on a policy valued at more than $900,000.

In a related story titled Lott's lawyer: State Farm is destroying fraud evidence, Michael Kunzelman reports:
Zach Scruggs, one of [U.S. Sen. Trent] Lott's attorneys, says Lott has a "good faith belief" that several State Farm employees in Biloxi are destroying engineering reports that gave conflicting conclusions about whether wind or water was responsible for storm damage.

. . .

In an interview Monday, Scruggs said corporate "whistle-blowers" who are cooperating with Lott's attorneys have provided evidence that State Farm employees are destroying or moving those "initial favorable" engineering reports.

"We believe that this is a systematic practice," said Scruggs, who is Lott's nephew by marriage.

Mississippi Attorney General Jim Hood also says he is investigating allegations that State Farm manipulated engineering reports to deny claims after the Aug. 29 hurricane.

A judge ordered State Farm to turn over copies of its Katrina engineering reports to Hood's office. The judge also ordered Hood's office to set up a "Chinese wall" that would keep the documents out of the hands of lawyers with civil cases against State Farm.

. . .

Scruggs is asking a federal judge to order State Farm to turn over Lott's entire case file as well as records for other policyholders' claims.

This is surely not the last we will hear about this dirty business. Stay tuned.

Tuesday, April 03, 2007

Still Unanswered: Who Forged the Documents that Led to the Iraq War

Josh Marshall's team at TPM is still on the lonely case -- the world's biggest unsolved mystery story that almost nobody seems to have any interest in solving. As the Blog Brief has repeatedly asked: Who forged the forged documents?

The Washington Post went front page today with the whole forgery conspiracy, but as Paul Kiel at TPM explains, almost the whole article is devoted to irrelevancies and side points:
It doesn't really tell how a bogus letter became a case for war. In that story, the beginning and the end would be of utmost importance -- the beginning being the origin of the documents, the end the Bush administration's suppression of their fraudulence.
The real story is reduced to two sentences that don't appear until the very end of the article:
It remains unclear who fabricated the documents. Intelligence officials say most likely it was rogue elements in Sismi who wanted to make money selling them.

Sunday, April 09, 2006

So Where DID Those Forged Niger-Uranium Documents Come From?


This scandal continues to percolate. You'd think such a juicy story involving forged documents, spys, coverups, intrigues leading to war, and so on would generate a bit more interest from the major U.S. news organizations.

Thankfully, Josh Marshall continues to follow breaking developments, raking the muck and connecting dots. He offers a skeptical take on today's London Times article, "'Forgers' of key Iraq war contract named":
Now, remember, this version of events [described in the Times article] is the work of an Italian government 'investigation'. And all evidence suggests that the Italian government has very dirty hands in this whole affair, acting at least as the purveyor of the forgeries and possibly their creator as well.

Here's a few links to some of Josh's previous work on this subject, in case you missed it:
-- the FBI "reopening" its inquiry;
-- Hadley's role;
-- the "cleaning up" of the forgeries;
-- and the most detail is in "the Italian Connection," Part One, Part Two, and Part Three.

eriposte at The Left Coaster has (quite a bit) more.

Friday, January 05, 2007

Top 10 Congressional Investigations

Obviously, you could expand this list (post-Katrina waste and mismanagement?), but the Editors at the Poor Man Institute for Freedom and Democracy and a Pony has posted his Top 10 Most Anticipated Congressional Investigations for 2007.

Number 8 is the forgotten terror attack: the anthrax letters from over five years ago that were mailed to Senator Daschle, Tom Brokaw, Senator Leahy and others, killing five people and injuring seventeen. A less important but more amusing investigation to us denizens of Philadelphia would be number 9: Bush's lie about his alleged preference for cheez whiz on his cheesesteak (he actually likes American) in the wake of Senator Kerry's gaffe ordering his with swiss. What will we tell the children!?

I definitely second number 1, the long-promised but constantly "delayed" so-called "Phase 2" investigation on how the pre-Iraq War intelligence was used/skewed/manufactured by the Administration to serve its political ends.

Particularly, I still want to know -- who was responsible for the creation and distribution of the forged documents concerning uranium from Niger?

Wednesday, November 08, 2006

Destroying Incipient Myths about Last Night

"The Democrats who won have one thing in common -- aggressive and unapologetic opposition to what the Republicans have become."

Glenn's right: this win signals that the voters have had enough with the old ruling party. This was not a win for mealy-mouthed centrism. There will not be some kind of non-confrontational kum-bah-yah session where everyone sits down with Bush and agrees that all we need to do to fix Iraq is replace Rumsfeld.

First of all, how are Democrats supposedly going to "work with" a President who has steadfastly refused to work with them? Who has questioned the patriotism of anyone willing to question his wars? Who has said if the Democrats win, America loses? Who has refused to even inform Congress of his spying programs that violate federal law? Who has long since abandoned any vestiges of bipartisonship in favor of Grover Norquist's theory that it is a form of "date rape"?

Tom Delay has as much as dared the new 110th Congress to investigate his 109th: “My only answer to that,” DeLay replied, “is make my day.” (Here's a handy rundown of 109 of the 109th Congress' misdeeds). Cheney has already vowed not to appear if he is subpoenaed for testimony.

There is no evidence that voters do not want aggressive oversight of Bush's failures and the Republican scandals such as the constitutional oversteps on domestic spying and legalized torture, the destruction of habeas corpus, the rampant corruption, the unchecked war profiteering, the K Street Project, the Medicare donut, universal healthcare, energy independence, the never-investigated ethics violations, the failure to raise the minimum wage, etc. etc.

For that matter, who, exactly, was behind the forged Niger documents that helped drag us into the war? What about the promised-but-never-undertaken Phase 2 of the pre-war Iraq intelligence investigation--the one investigating how the "flawed" intelligence was used? And now that we're there in Iraq, how do we get out without making matters even worse?

Exit poll after exit poll show that voters are worried about Iraq and they are worried about corruption. These were the issues driving people to vote. Problems like these are not fixed without aggressive hearings to look into them. These are not issues that can be fixed without hurting the feelings of or embarrassing the people who made them problems in the first place. There isn't a polite way of uncovering your colleagues' corruption or the corruption of their campaign contributors.

The Republican Congress has been rightfully maligned and rejected for failing to provide any checks on the idiocy and criminal acts (see: warrantless domestic wiretapping and data-mining) of the Bush Administration. Why would voters who just voted them out of office be expecting the new Democratic Congress to just quietly go along with the status quo? Among other things, voters want the Democrats to start doing what the Republicans largely gave up on--supervising the President.

And yet here we have Rahm Emanuel in the Washington Post, the day after a historic Democratic victory, lowering expectations, and stabbing ranking House members in the back as being "too liberal":
In private talks before the election, Emanuel and other top Democrats told their members they cannot allow the party's liberal wing to dominate the agenda next year. Democrats will hold 30 or 35 seats that went for Bush in the past, meaning that Democratic candidates such as Brad Ellsworth in rural Indiana are likely to face competitive races again in 2008. Still, their interests are likely to collide with those of veteran liberals such as Reps. Henry A. Waxman (Calif.) and John Conyers Jr., (Mich.), who will chair committees.
Where does Rahm get off criticizing Charlie Rangel and Henry Waxman before they even sit down in their new committee chairmanships? Until yesterday, Rahm couldn't condemn DNC Chair Howard Dean or his 50-State Strategy quickly enough--the very strategy that got them where they are today. The meme then was that Dean and the liberal bloggers were wasting money on unwinnable races. Now, with those "unwinnable" races won, we are to believe that it's because America is not interested in the changes promised by the winners?

And the spin that this was a win for "moderates" simply because pro-war Lieberman and pro-life Casey won ignores substantial evidence that voters were rejecting moderates with Rs after their name. Democratic challengers sweep into House seats in districts that everybody but Howard Dean and progressive-minded internet bloggers had largely written off only a few weeks ago. Lincoln Chafee, the ultimate Republican moderate--lost. DeWine, a so-called GOP moderate from a swing state--lost his Senate seat in a landslide to one of the most liberal voices from the House, Sherrod Brown. The entire northeast has turned a deep, deep blue. A socialist just won a Senate seat in Vermont.

The culture of corruption, the lies and false assurances about Iraq, the pro-torture pronouncements from what are supposed to be leaders of the country... all of this was rejected, and in dramatic fashion.

This was an unprecedented shut out. There is no spinning that away.

Look at the results: the Republicans failed to pick up a single governorship or a single House or Senate seat. That has never happened before. Look at the results: 32 million Americans voted for Democratic Senate candidates, while only 24 million voted for Republicans. That's over a 13% margin of victory!

Bush, for once, will be the one who will have to compromise.

Update:

Markos destroys the myth about just how "conservative" the new Democrats are. Obviously they are "moderate" or "conservative" in comparison the wild-eyed right-wing fringe that has been operating unimpeded for the last six years, but they are hardly "conservatives" as that term has come to be known. Ezra Klein has more on this topic. More from Dave Neiwert. More from Mimikatz at the Next Hurrah.

Rick Perlstein of TNR credits the "netroots" and blogs for the victories before Rahm Emanuel.

Second Update:

Digby takes to the issue too:
. . . Democrats come back into the majority in the House with a huge, decisive victory and the Senate is poised to tip as well and the press seems to be interpreting this election as a .... repudiation of the soft and squishy hated liberals. (Again, they are taking their cues from Rush Limbaugh who is also spinning the election as a loss for liberals.) The narrative is suspended in amber.

It's wrong, of course, just as the earlier one was. This election proves that the Democrats are the mainstream political party. We just elected a socialist from Vermont and a former Reagan official from Virginia to the US Senate. We elected a number of Red State conservatives, true, but we are also going to have a Speaker of the House from San Francisco. We cover a broad swathe, ranging from sea to shining sea with only the most conservative old south remaining firmly in the hands of the Republican party. The idea that this is some sort of affirmation of conservatism is laughable. It's an affirmation of mainstream American values and a rejection of the Republican radicalism this country has been in the grips of for the last 12 years.

And I'm sorry to have to inform all the kewl kidz and insiders, but this is largely due to the re-emergence of an active, vital, progressive base. Despite the fact that we aren't goosestepping around shouting about our Victory For The Homeland the way the Gingrich Juden did in 1994, a revolution --- not of ideology, but necessity --- is underway

. . .

And regardless of our pragmatism, make no mistake: real fighting progressives are once again active players in this game, coming in with money and energy and ideas. As Perlstein's piece shows, this new group of energized progressives are not children, 60's hippies or fools. We are not asking for a seat at the table. We're not begging for a voice. Neither are we crazed ideological revolutionaries in the Gingrichian mold. We're simply progressive American citizens who are taking our seat and demanding our say after 12 long years of being shunted aside as if we have no place in this party or this country.
There's quite a bit more here.

Wednesday, May 31, 2006

A Pennsylvania Landslide?

Chris Bowers at MyDD predicts a landslide election for the Democratic Party in Pennsylvania on the strength of "an extremely vibrant, emerging progressive movement statewide." He believes early polling and the May 16 primary results auger well for progressives both here and nationally:

For those of you who still believe that fighting internal Democratic battles is somehow a waste of progressive resources, you need to look no further than to Pennsylvania for counter-evidence. While the newly revitalized progressive movement in Pennsylvania has locked horns with the party establishment, the result has not been drained resources and two separate, warring factions. Instead, the result has been a tremendous upswing in pro-Democratic Party activity in Pennsylvania that has benefited both the new progressive movement and the party establishment. Our new progressive movement is working--the old ways of either simply falling in line behind the party leaders or bolting the party / sitting on your hands were not working. The progressive, internal reform movement has identified hundreds of new activists, resulted in a tremendous fundraising upswing, created new progressive media outlets, started new grassroots organizations, and forged new progressive social networking spaces. This is how you do it. This is how a progressive movement can win back Pennsylvania, and indeed the entire nation.